Why do the 3s 3p and 3d orbitals have the same energy in hydrogen atom but different energies in many electron atoms?

For an atom or an ion with only a single electron, we can calculate the potential energy by considering only the electrostatic attraction between the positively charged nucleus and the negatively charged electron. When more than one electron is present, however, the total energy of the atom or the ion depends not only on attractive electron-nucleus interactions but also on repulsive electron-electron interactions. When there are two electrons, the repulsive interactions depend on the positions of both electrons at a given instant, but because we cannot specify the exact positions of the electrons, it is impossible to exactly calculate the repulsive interactions. Consequently, we must use approximate methods to deal with the effect of electron-electron repulsions on orbital energies.

If an electron is far from the nucleus (i.e., if the distance r between the nucleus and the electron is large), then at any given moment, most of the other electrons will be between that electron and the nucleus. Hence the electrons will cancel a portion of the positive charge of the nucleus and thereby decrease the attractive interaction between it and the electron farther away. As a result, the electron farther away experiences an effective nuclear charge (Zeff)The nuclear charge an electron actually experiences because of shielding from other electrons closer to the nucleus. that is less than the actual nuclear charge Z. This effect is called electron shieldingThe effect by which electrons closer to the nucleus neutralize a portion of the positive charge of the nucleus and thereby decrease the attractive interaction between the nucleus and an electron father away.. As the distance between an electron and the nucleus approaches infinity, Zeff approaches a value of 1 because all the other (Z − 1) electrons in the neutral atom are, on the average, between it and the nucleus. If, on the other hand, an electron is very close to the nucleus, then at any given moment most of the other electrons are farther from the nucleus and do not shield the nuclear charge. At r ≈ 0, the positive charge experienced by an electron is approximately the full nuclear charge, or Zeff ≈ Z. At intermediate values of r, the effective nuclear charge is somewhere between 1 and Z: 1 ≤ Zeff ≤ Z. Thus the actual Zeff experienced by an electron in a given orbital depends not only on the spatial distribution of the electron in that orbital but also on the distribution of all the other electrons present. This leads to large differences in Zeff for different elements, as shown in Figure 2.5.9 for the elements of the first three rows of the periodic table. Notice that only for hydrogen does Zeff = Z, and only for helium are Zeff and Z comparable in magnitude.

Why do the 3s 3p and 3d orbitals have the same energy in hydrogen atom but different energies in many electron atoms?

Figure 2.5.9 Relationship between the Effective Nuclear Charge Zeff and the Atomic Number Z for the Outer Electrons of the Elements of the First Three Rows of the Periodic Table Except for hydrogen, Zeff is always less than Z, and Zeff increases from left to right as you go across a row.

The trend that you see in Figure 2.5.9 for the first three principal shells corresponding to n= 1, 2, and 3, continues in the further shells. The atomic number and thus the nuclear charge increase linearly, but the sawtooth pattern for Zeff repeats itself, resetting as the quantum number n changes. Chemical bonding and reactivity involves the sharing or exchange of electrons between atoms. Those electrons which can participate are those held least strongly by the atom, the outermost electrons, which, no matter what the atomic number, and nuclear charge, are bound to their atom by roughly the same energy range because of the shielding effect.

In multielectron atoms this shifts the energies of the different orbitals for a typical multielectron atom as shown in Figure 2.5.10 . Within a given principal shell of a multielectron atom, the orbital energies increase with increasing l. An ns orbital always lies below the corresponding np orbital, which in turn lies below the nd orbital. These energy differences are caused by the effects of shielding and penetration, the extent to which a given orbital lies inside other filled orbitals. As shown in Figure 2.5.11 for example, an electron in the 2s orbital penetrates inside a filled 1s orbital more than an electron in a 2p orbital does. Hence in an atom with a filled 1s orbital, the Zeff experienced by a 2s electron is greater than the Zeff experienced by a 2p electron. Consequently, the 2s electron is more tightly bound to the nucleus and has a lower energy, consistent with the order of energies shown in Figure 2.5.10

Due to electron shielding, Zeff increases more rapidly going across a row of the periodic table than going down a column.

Why do the 3s 3p and 3d orbitals have the same energy in hydrogen atom but different energies in many electron atoms?

Figure 2.5.10 Orbital Energy Level Diagram for a Typical Multielectron Atom

Because of the effects of shielding and the different radial distributions of orbitals with the same value of n but different values of l, the different subshells are not degenerate in a multielectron atom. (Compare this with Figure 2.5.8 For a given value of n, the ns orbital is always lower in energy than the np orbitals, which are lower in energy than the nd orbitals, and so forth. As a result, some subshells with higher principal quantum numbers are actually lower in energy than subshells with a lower value of n; for example, the 4s orbital is lower in energy than the 3d orbitals for most atoms.

Why do the 3s 3p and 3d orbitals have the same energy in hydrogen atom but different energies in many electron atoms?

Figure 2.5.11 Orbital Penetration A comparison of the radial probability distribution of the 2s and 2p orbitals for various states of the hydrogen atom shows that the 2s orbital penetrates inside the 1s orbital more than the 2p orbital does. Consequently, when an electron is in the small inner lobe of the 2s orbital, it experiences a relatively large value of Zeff, which causes the energy of the 2s orbital to be lower than the energy of the 2p orbital.

Notice in Figure 2.5.10 that the difference in energies between subshells can be so large that the energies of orbitals from different principal shells can become approximately equal. For example, the energy of the 3d orbitals in most atoms is actually between the energies of the 4s and the 4p orbitals.

energy of hydrogen-like orbitals

Equation 2.5.4: \( E=-\dfrac{Z^{2}}{n^{2}}\mathcal{R}hc \)

Because of wave–particle duality, scientists must deal with the probability of an electron being at a particular point in space. To do so required the development of quantum mechanics, which uses wave functions (Ψ) to describe the mathematical relationship between the motion of electrons in atoms and molecules and their energies. Wave functions have five important properties: (1) the wave function uses three variables (Cartesian axes x, y, and z) to describe the position of an electron; (2) the magnitude of the wave function is proportional to the intensity of the wave; (3) the probability of finding an electron at a given point is proportional to the square of the wave function at that point, leading to a distribution of probabilities in space that is often portrayed as an electron density plot; (4) describing electron distributions as standing waves leads naturally to the existence of sets of quantum numbers characteristic of each wave function; and (5) each spatial distribution of the electron described by a wave function with a given set of quantum numbers has a particular energy.

Quantum numbers provide important information about the energy and spatial distribution of an electron. The principal quantum number n can be any positive integer; as n increases for an atom, the average distance of the electron from the nucleus also increases. All wave functions with the same value of n constitute a principal shell in which the electrons have similar average distances from the nucleus. The azimuthal quantum number l can have integral values between 0 and n − 1; it describes the shape of the electron distribution. Wave functions that have the same values of both n and l constitute a subshell, corresponding to electron distributions that usually differ in orientation rather than in shape or average distance from the nucleus. The magnetic quantum number ml can have 2l + 1 integral values, ranging from −l to +l, and describes the orientation of the electron distribution. Each wave function with a given set of values of n, l, and ml describes a particular spatial distribution of an electron in an atom, an atomic orbital.

The four chemically important types of atomic orbital correspond to values of l = 0, 1, 2, and 3. Orbitals with l = 0 are s orbitals and are spherically symmetrical, with the greatest probability of finding the electron occurring at the nucleus. All orbitals with values of n > 1 and l = 0 contain one or more nodes. Orbitals with l = 1 are p orbitals and contain a nodal plane that includes the nucleus, giving rise to a dumbbell shape. Orbitals with l = 2 are d orbitals and have more complex shapes with at least two nodal surfaces. Orbitals with l = 3 are f orbitals, which are still more complex.

Because its average distance from the nucleus determines the energy of an electron, each atomic orbital with a given set of quantum numbers has a particular energy associated with it, the orbital energy. In atoms or ions with only a single electron, all orbitals with the same value of n have the same energy (they are degenerate), and the energies of the principal shells increase smoothly as n increases. An atom or ion with the electron(s) in the lowest-energy orbital(s) is said to be in its ground state, whereas an atom or ion in which one or more electrons occupy higher-energy orbitals is said to be in an excited state.

The calculation of orbital energies in atoms or ions with more than one electron (multielectron atoms or ions) is complicated by repulsive interactions between the electrons. The concept of electron shielding, in which intervening electrons act to reduce the positive nuclear charge experienced by an electron, allows the use of hydrogen-like orbitals and an effective nuclear charge (Zeff) to describe electron distributions in more complex atoms or ions. The degree to which orbitals with different values of l and the same value of n overlap or penetrate filled inner shells results in slightly different energies for different subshells in the same principal shell in most atoms.

Key Takeaway

  • There is a relationship between the motions of electrons in atoms and molecules and their energies that is described by quantum mechanics.

Conceptual Problems

  1. Why does an electron in an orbital with n = 1 in a hydrogen atom have a lower energy than a free electron (n = ∞)?

  2. What four variables are required to fully describe the position of any object in space? In quantum mechanics, one of these variables is not explicitly considered. Which one and why?

  3. Chemists generally refer to the square of the wave function rather than to the wave function itself. Why?

  4. Orbital energies of species with only one electron are defined by only one quantum number. Which one? In such a species, is the energy of an orbital with n = 2 greater than, less than, or equal to the energy of an orbital with n = 4? Justify your answer.

  5. In each pair of subshells for a hydrogen atom, which has the higher energy? Give the principal and the azimuthal quantum number for each pair.

    1. 1s, 2p
    2. 2p, 2s
    3. 2s, 3s
    4. 3d, 4s

  6. What is the relationship between the energy of an orbital and its average radius? If an electron made a transition from an orbital with an average radius of 846.4 pm to an orbital with an average radius of 476.1 pm, would an emission spectrum or an absorption spectrum be produced? Why?

  7. In making a transition from an orbital with a principal quantum number of 4 to an orbital with a principal quantum number of 7, does the electron of a hydrogen atom emit or absorb a photon of energy? What would be the energy of the photon? To what region of the electromagnetic spectrum does this energy correspond?

  8. What quantum number defines each of the following?

    1. the overall shape of an orbital
    2. the orientation of an electron with respect to a magnetic field
    3. the orientation of an orbital in space
    4. the average energy and distance of an electron from the nucleus

  9. In an attempt to explain the properties of the elements, Niels Bohr initially proposed electronic structures for several elements with orbits holding a certain number of electrons, some of which are in the following table:

    1. Draw the electron configuration of each atom based only on the information given in the table. What are the differences between Bohr’s initially proposed structures and those accepted today?
    2. Using Bohr’s model, what are the implications for the reactivity of each element?
    3. Give the actual electron configuration of each element in the table.

  10. What happens to the energy of a given orbital as the nuclear charge Z of a species increases? In a multielectron atom and for a given nuclear charge, the Zeff experienced by an electron depends on its value of l. Why?

  11. The electron density of a particular atom is divided into two general regions. Name these two regions and describe what each represents.

  12. As the principal quantum number increases, the energy difference between successive energy levels decreases. Why? What would happen to the electron configurations of the transition metals if this decrease did not occur?

  13. Describe the relationship between electron shielding and Zeff on the outermost electrons of an atom. Predict how chemical reactivity is affected by a decreased effective nuclear charge.

  14. If a given atom or ion has a single electron in each of the following subshells, which electron is easier to remove?

    1. 2s, 3s
    2. 3p, 4d
    3. 2p, 1s
    4. 3d, 4s

Numerical Problems

  1. How many subshells are possible for n = 3? What are they?

  2. How many subshells are possible for n = 5? What are they?

  3. What value of l corresponds to a d subshell? How many orbitals are in this subshell?

  4. What value of l corresponds to an f subshell? How many orbitals are in this subshell?

  5. State the number of orbitals and electrons that can occupy each subshell.

  6. State the number of orbitals and electrons that can occupy each subshell.

  7. How many orbitals and subshells are found within the principal shell n = 6? How do these orbital energies compare with those for n = 4?

  8. How many nodes would you expect a 4p orbital to have? A 5s orbital?

  9. A p orbital is found to have one node in addition to the nodal plane that bisects the lobes. What would you predict to be the value of n? If an s orbital has two nodes, what is the value of n?

Answers

  1. Three subshells, with l = 0 (s), l = 1 (p), and l = 2 (d).

  2.  
  3. A d subshell has l = 2 and contains 5 orbitals.

  4.  
    1. 2 electrons; 1 orbital
    2. 6 electrons; 3 orbitals
    3. 10 electrons; 5 orbitals
    4. 14 electrons; 7 orbitals

  5.  
  6. A principal shell with n = 6 contains six subshells, with l = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, respectively. These subshells contain 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, and 11 orbitals, respectively, for a total of 36 orbitals. The energies of the orbitals with n = 6 are higher than those of the corresponding orbitals with the same value of l for n = 4.

  7.  
  8.