When do accidents fall off insurance

17Aug2016

In Florida, car accidents generally stay on your record anywhere from three to five years. Florida is a no-fault state so that really whether you’re involved in an accident should not affect the premium that you pay for your insurance unless you are cited for causing the accident and the insurance company had to pay out money to fix the other person’s car or to pay money for harm that you caused, those will affect rates.

Every insurance company has their own point system that they use, which will have their own in-house formula to determine what they’re gonna charge for rates. I always tell people to shop it around because even though you may feel an attachment to the insurance company because you’ve been with them 20 years, the insurance company does not look at it that way.

So car accidents are a public record and I can hire private investigators that can find all of the accidents that people have been in, probably over the course of their whole life, and I often do that in cases where the defendant driver is driving a corporate vehicle or a company-owned vehicle because I can often show that that person had no business driving for the company. When you pull up the prior records, that puts the case in its proper perspective for a jury to look at and see what should happen to that company.

When do accidents fall off insurance

Jim Holliday has recovered millions of dollars for his clients in restitution for their injuries.

In this article:

Car insurance companies consider multiple factors when determining your rates, including your driving record. Your history as a driver holds a lot of weight, as it helps insurers assess risk and better understand how likely you are to file a future claim. If you have a recent auto accident on your driving record, it's something that could translate to higher rates—especially if it's accompanied by moving violations, such as speeding tickets.

The silver lining is that an accident's impact on your premiums isn't permanent. Many insurance companies only consider the last three to five years of your driving record when calculating your rates, although the exact length of time can vary by state and insurance company.

To be clear, that doesn't necessarily mean that a previous accident will be removed from your driving record after a period of time—it's just to say that insurers typically won't factor it into your rates. In other words, an accident from six years ago might still be on your driving record, but it might not have a huge impact on your car insurance rates—assuming you've continued to demonstrate responsible driving since then.

Wondering how long an accident will stay on your insurance? Let's first unpack how it affects your insurance rates in the short term.

Since your driving record influences your car insurance premiums, an accident could bump up your insurance costs. However, it doesn't mean that your rates will definitely skyrocket if you're involved in an accident. In some cases, they may not change at all if you weren't at fault or if it's your first accident. You're likely to see a rate hike if you've been involved in other accidents over the past few years. And, again, the same goes for moving violations.

Insurers look at the big picture when determining your risk profile and, in turn, your rates. In this way, accidents and citations can stack on top of each other to increase your premium. Your rates could also go up after an accident if the other driver doesn't have enough insurance to cover the damage. In this situation, you might have to utilize your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, which could trigger a rate increase.

It's also helpful to think in terms of individual claims. A minor fender bender will likely result in a smaller claim when compared to a collision that causes serious damage or injuries. Let's say you get into an accident that's primarily your fault. If you file a claim with your insurance company that exceeds a specific amount, your premium will spike by a correlating percentage, according to the Insurance Information Institute. The correlation varies from insurer to insurer, and you can expect that rate hike to be there as long as your insurer considers the accident as a factor in your rate.

In some cases, an accident could result in your car being totaled, which is when the overall cost of repairs outweighs the value of the car. At that point, your insurer may provide a payout equivalent to your car's actual cash value. The value of a vehicle is typically determined by the vehicle's make and model, age, mileage and condition, among other factors, at the time of the accident. It's essentially a rough estimate of how much the car could have reasonably sold for had it not been totaled.

Your driving record isn't the only factor that affects your auto insurance rates. Every state has its own minimum coverage requirements, and rates tend to vary from state to state. Things like your gender, age and marital status and how much you drive can all come into play as well. And if you opt for a pricier car that's more expensive to repair or more likely to be stolen, you could end up paying a higher premium. Moreover, insuring a car that's leased or financed tends to be more expensive as your lessor or lender will likely require you to purchase additional coverage.

A policy that has a higher deductible, which is the amount you'll pay in out-of-pocket costs before your policy coverage kicks in, generally comes with lower premiums, and vice versa. Just bear in mind that a high deductible could be costly in the event that you have to file a claim.

In most states, car insurance companies can also consider your credit when determining your rates by using a credit-based insurance score. Like your consumer credit scores, credit-based insurance scores are based on things like your debt payment history and account balances. If you have a high credit score, it's likely you also have a high credit-based insurance score. Having a strong score can unlock lower rates because it suggests that you may be less likely to file a claim in the future.

Besides being patient and waiting for the accident to no longer be considered, there are ways you may be able to offset an increase in your car insurance rates following an accident. Improving your credit is a great place to start: Even simple moves, like making timely debt payments and reducing your outstanding credit card balances, could have a big impact if your state allows the use of credit scores in insurance pricing. Review your credit by checking your free credit report and scores from Experian.

Another way to bring down high premiums is to explore discounts. Your insurer may offer discounts for students, military service members and seniors. You may also be able to shave your costs by bundling your auto coverage with your renters or homeowners insurance policies. Some insurers offer discounts to policyholders who take a defensive driving course or demonstrate safe driving for a certain period of time. No matter what discounts your current auto insurer may offer, be sure to shop around and compare quotes with other carriers to find the best rate.

If possible, it could help to reduce the number of miles you drive annually. Your average mileage plays a significant role in determining your risk and, by extension, your insurance rates. If you've started working from home or got a new job with a shorter commute, be sure to alert your insurance company so your premium can take your new driving habits into account.

The Bottom Line

Whether it's an accident, a moving violation or a traffic citation, a blemish on your driving record can spark an increase in your car insurance premiums. These types of rate increases typically last anywhere from three to five years, assuming you don't incur any new infractions. Improving your credit in the meantime could help reduce your premiums—and strengthen your overall financial health in the process.

4.8out of 3,000+ reviews

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.

Advertising disclosures

When do accidents fall off insurance

Your driving record can be a mysterious thing. What exactly is on there—and how long does it stick around? The good news: you probably don’t need to stress about that car accident you were in more than five years ago, even if you were at fault.

Regardless of your driving history, it’s always a good idea to compare quotes so you can save money on your auto insurance coverage. Use Insurify to compare the cheapest car insurance quotes from national providers like Progressive and GEICO along with local providers so you can quickly find the best deal for auto insurance rates.

  • A driver with an accident on their record will pay an average of $32 more per month for car insurance than a driver with a clean record.

  • The cheapest insurer we found for drivers with an accident on their record is Metromile, with average premiums of $112 per month.

  • If you maintain a clean driving record after your first accident, you will likely see your premiums decrease after just a few years.

Drivers can expect an accident to stay on their driving record for at least three years. However, the length of time an accident will affect insurance premiums depends on the severity of the accident and whether or not the driver has a history of car accidents.

You can’t change your past driving record, but you can change how much you pay for car insurance. Below are cheapest insurance companies for drivers with past accidents on their driving record, drawn from Insurify’s proprietary database of millions of driver quotes.

Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

See More: Best Car Insurance Companies

  • Personalized quotes in 5 minutes or less
  • No signup required

Unlike some types of records, car accidents and other motor vehicle-related incidents don’t automatically disappear from your driving record after a set length of time. Instead, different factors can be responsible for determining how long an accident stays on your record.

You already know that car insurance companies look at your driving record when offering you a quote or even when they reevaluate your insurance rates. Typically, you can expect that an accident on your record—whether or not you were at fault—will affect your rates for at least three years.

This higher premium will be the result of what’s called a surcharge. Over those three years or so, your rates will spike and then steadily decline. But if you’ve had a streak of accidents, be prepared for those rate changes to last even longer than that.

After a major accident, regardless of whose fault it was, it’s a good idea to do your best to avoid additional accidents or citations for at least six years. This reduces the risk of an additional rate increase and improves the odds of that accident being erased after the default three years.

Curious about how a new auto insurance policy will reflect your bad driving record? Use Insurify to get free customized insurance quotes and get the cheapest rate based on your personal driving history.

See More: Car Insurance Quotes

A prior accident tends to have a negative impact on your car insurance premiums. Check out the table below comparing average monthly premiums for drivers with a prior accident compared to those without for typical minimum liability and full-coverage car insurance policies.

Prior accident?Average Monthly RateCoverage Type
Yes$206Minimum Liability Coverage
No$158Minimum Liability Coverage
Yes$302Full-Coverage
No$285Full-Coverage

Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Need an idea of how quotes change with an accident in your driving history? The quotes listed below correspond to a driver having a clean driving record, an at-fault accident from six months ago on their record, and an at-fault accident from four years ago on their record.

Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

It’s ideal to have a clean driving record. But auto accidents happen, even to safe drivers. Surcharges will cause this driver’s auto rates to spike. However over time, auto premiums will decrease back to near their original levels. In two more years, the driver’s accident will be more or less scrubbed from her record.

While major accidents do typically affect your insurance premiums—at least temporarily—minor accidents that can be resolved without filing a claim won’t. Insurance companies only know about the accidents eported to them. If you’re involved in a minor fender-bender and are able to resolve it on your own without your insurance company, you’ll avoid seeing a premium increase.

See More: Cheap Car Insurance

Again, it depends. Insurance companies don’t have a straightforward method for calculating rate increases. Instead, factors like your age, your existing driving record, credit score, and even where you live can all play a role. As a general rule, experienced drivers with a relatively clean record will see less of a rate increase than a younger driver with a few citations.

You can see this reflected in many insurance companies’ good driver discounts. Other car insurance companies offer accident forgiveness for customers who have a demonstrated history of good driving. With accident forgiveness, the insurance company essentially doesn’t count the accident when calculating your premium. Usually, this policy only applies to your first accident.

The severity of the accident also plays a role, too. A minor no-fault accident that doesn’t result in any injuries is unlikely to result in a sky-high rate hike. On the other hand, a major accident with injuries or property damage or an at-fault accident such as a hit-and-run is far more likely to affect your premiums.

See More: Best and Worst Sites to Compare Car Insurance

Insurance companies often classify drivers as “high-risk” if they have a DUI or multiple citations or accidents on their record. Adjusting your habits to ensure you drive defensively and safely can give you big benefits when your monthly bill rolls around.

Although it may be difficult to determine how exactly an accident will affect your monthly premiums, the best defense is a good offense. If your driving history is less than stellar, it’s never too late to start improving it. If you have a longstanding history of good driving habits, keep it up! Whether you realize it or not, it’s saving you a bit of money every month.

Insurify lets you compare auto insurance quotes from top insurance providers across the nation with ease, no matter your driving record or financial situation. Insurance costs don’t have to be debilitating. Build your ideal policy and secure a cheaper quote today!

  • When do accidents fall off insurance

    While accidents and traffic violations such as speeding tickets will usually raise your insurance rates, comparing personalized quotes from multiple auto insurance companies will help you find the best insurance premium. You can also always save by bundling your car insurance with your renters or home insurance.

  • Although it may be difficult to determine exactly how long an accident will stay on your insurance record and affect your auto insurance premiums, it’s important to try and maintain a clean driving record following an accident. If you have only one accident in your driving history, your rates will go down.

  • If you are involved in a minor fender-bender that you are able to financially resolve on your own, you do not have to file a claim with your insurance company. However, it’s important to note that minor accidents with no injuries or significant property damage may only raise your rates slightly and won’t break the bank.

  • Personalized quotes in 5 minutes or less
  • No signup required

  • Methodology

    Data scientists at Insurify analyzed over 40 million auto insurance rates across the United States to compile the car insurance quotes, statistics, and data visualizations displayed on this page. The car insurance data includes coverage analysis and details on drivers' vehicles, driving records, and demographic information. With these insights, Insurify is able to offer drivers insight into how their car insurance premiums are priced by companies.