Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

If you're seeing this message, it means we're having trouble loading external resources on our website.

If you're behind a web filter, please make sure that the domains *.kastatic.org and *.kasandbox.org are unblocked.

Description: When a carboxylic acid is treated with an alcohol and an acid catalyst, an ester is formed (along with water). This reaction is called the Fischer esterification.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

Notes: The reaction is actually an equilibrium. The alcohol is generally used as solvent so is present in large excess. Many different acids can be used; it’s common to see just “H+”, although H2SO4 (sulfuric acid) and TsOH (tosic acid) are also often used.

Examples:

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

Notes: The byproduct of each of these reactions is water. Note that the third and fourth examples are intramolecular reactions that form a cyclic ester. Cyclic esters are also called lactones.

The fifth example shows that without any added alcohol, the only thing that happens is protonation of the carbonyl!

The sixth example is a double Fischer esterification.

Mechanism:

For such a seemingly simple reaction (replacement of OH by OR) there are actually a lot of steps. Protonation of the carbonyl oxygen by acid (Step 1, arrows A and B) makes the carbonyl carbon a much better electrophile. It undergoes 1,2-addition by the alcohol (Step 2, arrows C and D) whereupon the proton from the alcohol is transferred to one of the OH groups (Step 3, arrows E and F). Subsequent 1,2-elimination of water (Step 4, arrows G and H) leads to the protonated ester, and the ester is then deprotonated (Step 5, arrows I and J).

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

Notes:

  • All of these steps are in equilibrium

Note that the acid is a catalyst here (regenerated at the end) and serves two purposes. First, it makes the carbonyl carbon a better electrophile (Setting up step 2) and also allows for the loss of H2O as a leaving group (much better leaving group than HO–)

(Advanced) References and Further Reading

  1. First example
    Emil Fischer, Arthur Speier (1895). “Darstellung der Ester”.
    Chemische Berichte. 28: 3252–3258
    DOI: 
    1002/cber.189502803176
    Original paper by Emil Fischer and Arthur Speier describing acid-catalyzed esterification of carboxylic acids and alcohols.
  2. Protonic States and the Mechanism of Acid‐Catalysed Esterification Dr. H. Zimmermann Dr. J. Rudolph

    Angewandte Chemie Int. Ed., Volume 4, Issue 1, January 1965, Pages 40-49


    DOI: 10.1002/anie.196500401
    Considerations of proton mobility in the condensed phase suggest a two-step mechanism of esterification, which proceeds via a tetrahedral intermediate.
  3. Ethyl Adipate
    M. Micovic
    Org. Synth. Coll. Vol. 2, 264
    DOI: 10.15227/orgsyn.000.0001
    One of the first procedures in Organic Syntheses, a reliable source for reproducible organic transformations. This uses a Fischer esterification to convert adipic acid, a diacid and precursor to nylon-6,6, to ethyl adipate.

Let us look at the reactions of esters. We’ll start by exploring esterification and hydrolysis, and how we can change the reaction conditions to favour one or the other. We’ll then take a look at some of the uses of esters, including as biodiesel, oils, and soaps.

Esters react in various ways.

  • They are formed in esterification reactions between an alcohol and a carboxylic acid.
  • They can also be formed in acylation reactions between alcohols and either acyl chlorides, or acid anhydrides.
  • They are broken down in hydrolysis reactions using either a base or an acid as a catalyst. Base hydrolysis is also known as saponification.

What are esters?

Ethyl acetate, systematically known as ethyl ethanoate, is one of the most common esters. If you give it a sniff, it smells characteristically fruity, like pear drops. We use it in a variety of different ways: as a solvent and diluent, to decaffeinate coffee and tea leaves, as a flavouring, and in toiletries. It is commonly found in perfumes as it is quite volatile and evaporates off the skin readily, leaving behind its pleasant scent.

Esters are organic molecules with the functional group -COO-.

Esters are derived from carboxylic acids and have the general formula RCOOR', as shown below:

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
The general structure of an ester. The R groups can be alkyl or aryl groups. commons.wikimedia.org

Esters can be made in a variety of ways, but most commonly from carboxylic acids and alcohols. We name them using names based on these alcohols and carboxylic acids. The name derived from the alcohol comes first, followed by the name derived from the carboxylic acids. All esters end in the suffix -oate. For example, we call the ester made from propanol and methanoic acid propyl methanoate.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
Propyl methanoate. Propyl is derived from propanol, shown in green, whilst methanoate is derived from methanoic acid, shown in red. StudySmarter Originals

Let’s explore how we produce esters.

Esterification

Esterification is a reaction type that produces an ester. In this case, we react a carboxylic acid with an alcohol to produce an ester and water. This is a reversible reaction, meaning both the forward reaction and the backward reaction happen at the same time in a state of dynamic equilibrium.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
Esterification. You’ll see this diagram again later in the article. StudySmarter Originals

For more on reversible reactions, take a quick look at Equilibria.

Producing esters in a lab

Making esters is a common practical experiment that you might carry out in class.

To make esters at test tube scale, use a water bath to gently heat 10 drops of a carboxylic acid with 10 drops of an alcohol and 2 drops of a strong acid catalyst, such as sulfuric acid. You wouldn’t do this directly over an open flame because the organic liquids used are highly flammable.

Because this reaction is reversible, you’ll only produce a tiny amount of the ester. To smell it, pour the solution into a beaker of water. Longer chain esters are soluble, so will form a layer on top of the surface of the water, whilst the unreacted acid and alcohol will dissolve readily. If you waft the air over the top of the beaker, you should be able to smell the ester. Whilst short-chain esters such as methyl ethanoate, commonly known as methyl acetate, smell like solvents or glue, longer chain esters smell fruity and aromatic.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

A diagram showing the production of an ester in a test tube. StudySmarter Originals

Let’s have a go at writing an equation. For example, reacting ethanoic acid with butanol produces butyl ethanoate, which smells like raspberry.

ethanoic acid butanol butyl ethanoate water

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
Butyl ethanoate. In this ester, R comes from ethanoic acid, shown in red, whilst R' comes from butanol, shown in green. StudySmarter Originals

Large-scale ester production is a little different to test-tube ester production, and depends on the type of ester you want to create. To make short-chain esters such as ethyl ethanoate, CH3COOCH2CH3, heat ethanol and ethanoic acid with a strong, concentrated acid catalyst and distill off the product, i.e., the ester. The ester has the lowest boiling point out of all the substances involved because it cannot form hydrogen bonds with itself, unlike alcohols and carboxylic acids. Distilling off the product also shifts our equilibrium to the right, increasing the yield of the reaction.

However, if we want to make longer chain esters we have to use reflux. Reflux involves heating a reaction mixture in a sealed container. This means that any volatile components that evaporate condense and fall back into the reaction mixture, preventing them from evaporating before they can react. The products can then be separated by fractional distillation.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

Reflux apparatus set up for esterification.commons.wikimedia.org

We can also make esters in other ways, such as:

We’ll look at both of these reaction types in more detail in Acylation.

Hydrolysis of esters

We can break down esters in two similar ways, using either an acid or a base as a catalyst. These reactions are known as hydrolysis reactions.

Acid hydrolysis

We mentioned above that esterification is a reversible reaction. If you mix a carboxylic acid and an alcohol with an acid catalyst, eventually the solution will reach a state of dynamic equilibrium. This just means that the molecules are constantly changing form, some combining into an ester and releasing water, and some returning back to an alcohol and carboxylic acid. When at equilibrium, the rate of the forward esterification reaction is the same as the backward reaction: we call this backward reaction hydrolysis.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
Esterification and hydrolysis - two sides of the same reaction. StudySmarter Originals

To hydrolyse esters, mix them with a hot, aqueous acid under reflux conditions. In this case, the water from the aqueous acid acts as a nucleophile, which you’ll remember is an electron pair donor.

Favouring hydrolysis

You might know (see Equilibria) that we can change the conditions of a reversible reaction in order to favour one reaction or the other. Le Chatelier’s principle tells us that changing these conditions will cause the equilibrium to shift in the opposite direction to oppose the change. So how can we increase the rate of the backwards reaction, i.e., hydrolysis?

Well, one of the reactants is water. Therefore, by simply increasing the amount of water we use, we can favour the backward reaction. The equilibrium will move over to the left, to ‘use up’ the extra water we’ve added in. We do this by using an excess of the dilute acid catalyst. This is also why we use a concentrated acid to catalyse the forward reaction, esterification - using a minimal amount of water shifts the equilibrium to the right and increases the yield of the ester.

Although we can shift the position of the equilibrium, acid hydrolysis will never give us a 100 percent yield because it is one half of a reversible reaction.

Base hydrolysis

We mentioned above that acid hydrolysis never goes to completion - it is a reversible reaction. We can instead hydrolyse esters using a base as a catalyst. This reaction goes to completion. Heating a hot, aqueous base such as a hydroxide with an ester under reflux produces a carboxylate salt and an alcohol.

A salt is a compound formed when negatively charged ions ionically bond to positively charged cations. They form a giant lattice structure.

For example, reacting methyl ethanoate with sodium hydroxide solution produces methanol and sodium ethanoate:

Sodium ethanoate is our carboxylate salt. It is made up of positive sodium ions and negative ethanoate ions ionically bonded together.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
The structure of sodium ethanoate. StudySmarter Originals

But what if we want a pure carboxylic acid instead of a carboxylate salt? We can do the following:

  • Distill the alcohol off.
  • Add an excess of strong acid such as sulfuric acid or hydrochloric acid. This gives up an excess of ions.
  • The ions are collected by carboxylate ions in solution, forming a carboxylic acid.
  • Separate the carboxylic acid from the solution by further distillation.

Base hydrolysis is also known as saponification. Take a look at that term, and you’ll be able to guess what some specific carboxylate salts are used for - soap! We make soaps out of animal fats and vegetable oils, which we’ll explore later.

Comparing acid and base hydrolysis

The following table should help you summarise your knowledge of acid and base hydrolysis.

A table comparing acid and base hydrolysis of esters. StudySmarter Originals

Have a go at the following question.

Propyl ethanoate can be broken down by using either sulfuric acid or sodium hydroxide. For each reaction, write an equation and name the products formed.

First, let’s draw out propyl ethanoate. This will help us see its structure and figure out its component parts.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
Propyl ethanoate. StudySmarter Originals

Remember that esters are derived from carboxylic acids. Ethanoate tells us that the part of the molecule that comes from the acid is based on ethanoic acid. The other part of the name, propyl, tells us that the remainder of the molecule is based on a propyl chain. When the ester is broken down, this forms propanol.

Let’s now consider how propyl ethanoate is broken down using an acid. Remember that this is a reversible reaction - it doesn’t go to completion. The products are ethanoic acid and propanol.

Acid hydrolysis of propyl ethanoate produces ethanoic acid, right, and propanol, left. StudySmarter Originals

If we use a base, the reaction does go to completion - but it produces a carboxylate salt instead of a carboxylic acid. Because we used sodium hydroxide, the salt formed is sodium ethanoate.

Saponification

We mentioned above that we can make soaps out of different fats and oils. This is known as saponification.

Fats and oils, collectively known as lipids, are also called triglycerides. This is because they are based on the alcohol glycerol. Glycerol has three -OH groups. In a triglyceride, each -OH group forms a bond with a carboxylic acid that has a long hydrocarbon tail. Hydrolysing a triglyceride using a base breaks it back down into glycerol, which we use in medication or to improve the performance of athletes; and carboxylate salts, which we use as soaps.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction

A triglyceride, left, breaks down in saponification into glycerol, above, and a carboxylate ion, below. The carboxylate ion forms a salt. StudySmarter Originals

How do soaps work?

Carboxylate salts are ionic. In solution, they dissociate to form a positive metal ion and a negative carboxylate ion. The carboxylate ion contains a polar end with the -COO group, and a nonpolar hydrocarbon tail. The polar end bonds with water whilst the nonpolar end bonds with other nonpolar molecules such as lipids, helping fats like scum and grease mix with water and be washed away.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
A carboxylate salt. StudySmarter Originals

Biodiesel

In 2006, a shuttle bus operating at Yale University was successfully converted to run on 100 percent biodiesel - a form of renewable fuel derived from plants. This was a major step towards lowering the environmental impact of the transport industry. Before we finish, let’s quickly explore what biodiesel actually is.

Biodiesel is made from triglyceride esters from plant crops, such as rapeseed oil. When we react them with methanol using an alkali catalyst, we get long-chain methyl esters. We can burn these instead of fossil fuels. In fact, up to 10 percent of the diesel or petrol used in cars can be replaced by biodiesel without affecting their engines. Because biodiesel comes from quick-growing plant matter, it is carbon neutral, and a much more sustainable choice than fuels derived from crude oil.

Explain why increasing the amount of methanol may not always benefit the reaction
A methyl ester, like those found in biodiesel. commons.wikimedia.org

Reactions of Esters - Key takeaways

  • Esters are organic molecules with the functional group -COO-.

  • Esters are made in esterification reactions. These are reversible reactions between an alcohol and a carboxylic acid, using a strong acid as a catalyst.

  • Esters can be hydrolysed using an acid or a base. Acid hydrolysis is the reverse of esterification, and as a result doesn’t go to completion. Base hydrolysis produces a 100 percent yield, but produces a carboxylate salt instead of a carboxylic acid.

  • Base hydrolysis of esters is also known as saponification. When triglycerides are hydrolysed, they produce glycerol and long-chain carboxylate salts, which are commonly used as soaps.

  • Biodiesel is made from plant triglycerides and methanol. It is a sustainable fuel choice compared to crude oil.